9% of 11-year old boys can’t read! So what?
You can tell that news is sparse on the ground – unlike the snow. The newspapers have already done a blanket coverage on the snow and how the UK again skidded to a halt, so they can’t do that one again. Instead, the press is trumpeting on about how terrible it is that 9% of boys can’t read properly when they leave primary school.
Apparently BBC Radio 4 asked the Department of Education for the number of children who failed to reach level 2 reading age, the standard expected for seven-year olds, and found out that around 18000 boys aged 11 had a reading age of seven or less. This was in contrast to other statistics that have shown a steady rise in standards – with children achieving the expected minimum level 4 having gone up from 49% of children to 81% in the last 15 years.
Seemingly, even worse, in some areas – for example Nottingham – 15% of boys failed to get past the level 2 reading level.
The problem with all this isn’t the statistic but the lack of context. When reporting information (whether for competitive intelligence, general business or marketing research, or whatever) it is essential to include the context. A figure on its own is meaningless. In fact, those figures for Nottingham could be brilliant – if five years ago, 30% of boys had failed to get past the level 2 reading level. It would mean that the numbers of children failing had halved. Conversely if the number had gone up from 5% then this would be a massive indictment against the teaching profession who were failing to motivate and educate their pupils.
In fact, the original story from the BBC does give some context.
In 1995, the proportion of 11-year-olds getting Level 2 or below in English – the standard expected of a seven-year-old – was 7%. In 2010, it had fallen only to 5%.
The figures show the problem is worse for boys. Overall in England, 9% of them – about 18,000 – achieved a maximum of level 2 in reading.
This shows that in fact, performance has improved overall, with underachievers falling from 7% in 1995 to 5% of all children now. However without a longer-term trend it is impossible to put much value into the statistics – especially as other research reported by the BBC looking at seven year olds showed that children with special educational needs, and from deprived homes (meaning that they were entitled to free school meals), were the worst performers. A third (33.6%) of seven years olds on free school meals failed to reach the requisite level 2 in writing and 29.3% failed to reach this level for reading. In contrast, the children who did not receive free school meals did much better – only 12.1% failed to reach the required level for reading, and 15.5% for writing.
I’m actually surprised that some mathematically-challenged journalist hasn’t picked up on these figures and claimed that providing free school meals results in children under-performing at school. In reality, all the figures show is that such children have barriers to learning that schools have to try to overcome. This may be because the children are under-stimulated at home (and so start at a lower level than their peers), come from homes where English is not spoken by the parents or are of lower intelligence overall. (In fact, intelligence tends to fall on a normal curve. If 10% of children outperform – and have a reading age 3 years ahead of the norm, you can expect that a further 10% will have a reading age 3 years less than the norm).
The lesson from such statistics and reporting is simple: before publishing statistics in the press or in a business report provide a context.
This context can be temporal – looking at how figures change over time. In the case of the school statistics, they appear to have improved over the years for both the low and average achievers – a testament to the teaching profession. Context can also be seen when comparisons are made – as in the comparison between children on free school meals versus those not entitled to this benefit.
Strategic decisions based on figures should only be made when context is included. Without it, the figures mean nothing, and should be left to melt away, like snow.
Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Recent Posts
- Apple & disruptive innovation: 4 questions innovators need to ask before moving forward!
- X-mas Advertising: John Lewis, M&S and Debenhams Christmas Ad Campaigns Compared
- Competition or Co-operation? Collaborate & Co-operate to build and not to destroy.
- Freedom of Speech, Abuse and Social Media
- Pluralistic Ignorance
- Testing perceptions – Myers-Briggs and false appearances
- The iWatch – is this the next disruptive innovation from Apple?
- If you will it, it is no dream…
- The impact of disruptive innovation – on PCs and on Retail
- Why six-sigma, just-in-time and lean manufacturing are dangerous!
- Entrpreneurs 2012 – Con-Trick or Conference: a review!
- Microsoft’s Surface and Disruptive Innovation!
Archives
Topic List
Tag Cloud
Blogroll
- AWARE – Competitive Intelligence for Business Success AWARE’s web-site – lots of options to learn more about CI and MI.
- Julian's The Write Way – How to produce good documentation
- Miriyummy – recipes & stories behind them
Competitive Intelligence Blogs, etc.
Ideas for Marketing and Information
Search Information
Worth a visit...
Latest Tweets…
- 2 people followed me // automatically checked by fllwrs.com 2 days ago
- RT @DefoortConsult: Non-financial people often shy away from financial data, but they are very informative for your #CompetitorAnalysis. I… 3 days ago
- Do terms like P&L, Balance Sheet and Cash Flow give you a headache? If you're an information professional who needs… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 4 days ago
- Do terms like P&L, Balance Sheet and Cash Flow give you a headache? If you're an information professional who needs… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 5 days ago
- How the Insurgent and MAGA Right are Being Welded Together on the Streets of Washington D.C. bellingcat.com/news/americas/… 5 days ago
- The latest AWARE Weekly Update! paper.li/awareci?editio… Thanks to @HackENews @AricToler #osint #cybersecurity 5 days ago
- Are you a non-financial professional who needs to understand finances? Join me for a 2-hour $125 workshop on financ… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 1 week ago
- Are you a non-financial professional who needs to understand finances? Join me for a 2-hour $125 workshop on financ… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 1 week ago
- OSINT Guide To Bitcoin Investigations secjuice.com/osint-beginner… #osint 1 week ago
- The latest AWARE Weekly Update! paper.li/awareci?editio… Thanks to @2bproductive @osinteditor @infosecsanyam #osint #strategy 1 week ago
Competitive Intelligence News
- Surgical Equipment Market Competitive Intelligence, SWOT Analysis, Strategies, And Tracking Report 2020-2030 - KSU | The Sentinel Newspaper January 14, 2021Surgical Equipment Market Competitive Intelligence, SWOT Analysis, Strategies, And Tracking Report 2020-2030 KSU | The Sentinel Newspaper
- Competitive Intelligence Tools Market to Witness Massive Growth by Klue, Contify, Digimind, Kompyte - Press Release - Digital Journal January 14, 2021Competitive Intelligence Tools Market to Witness Massive Growth by Klue, Contify, Digimind, Kompyte - Press Release Digital Journal
- Competitive Intelligence Spotlight #40: Aruba Networks' Brian Greenberg on Marketing Campaign Intell, Analyst Skill Set - GovConWire December 22, 2020Competitive Intelligence Spotlight #40: Aruba Networks' Brian Greenberg on Marketing Campaign Intell, Analyst Skill Set GovConWire
- Competitive Intelligence Tools Market is projected to Witness the Highest Growth during 2020-2024 by Adthena Ltd, BuzzSumo Ltd., Cloo track Software , Consensus - KSU | The Sentinel Newspaper January 11, 2021Competitive Intelligence Tools Market is projected to Witness the Highest Growth during 2020-2024 by Adthena Ltd, BuzzSumo Ltd., Cloo track Software , Consensus KSU | The Sentinel Newspaper
- DevOps Outsourcing Service Market Global Segment Analysis, Opportunity Assessment, Competitive Intelligence, Industry Outlook 2021-2025 · Wall Street Call - Reported Times January 15, 2021DevOps Outsourcing Service Market Global Segment Analysis, Opportunity Assessment, Competitive Intelligence, Industry Outlook 2021-2025 · Wall Street Call Reported Times
I do agree with all the ideas you’ve offered in your post. They’re really convincing and will certainly work. Still, the posts are very short for beginners. Could you please lengthen them a little from subsequent time? Thank you for the post.