Freedom of Speech, Abuse and Social Media
Over the last year or so, social media sites have been attacked for allowing users to post abuse about other people onto their sites. These include examples of cyber-bullying on ask.fm or tweets on twitter calling for other users to be raped. The ask.fm posts have been implicated in a number of suicides while in one notable case, Sally Bercow, the wife of the Speaker of the UK Parliament, was found guilty of libel for a tweet she posted implying somebody else was a paedophile.
Abuse via social media seems new. In fact this sort of abuse is old. The difference is not the abuse itself, but the level of publicity it receives. In the middle of the 19th century an anonymous individual sent letters to various people in the rural English town of Tetbury threatening to burn their property. Agatha Christie‘s 1942/43 detective novel “The Moving Finger” tells a story of letters sent to people in the quiet town of Lymstock that resulted in the recipients committing suicide. Not so different from the ask.fm cyber-bulling (except that as a Mrs Marple story, things were not so simple and in fact the letters were used as a cover for murder).
Hate letters – often called poison pen letters – go along with anonymous or silent phone calls as one way warped minds try and subvert the minds of opponents or people they dislike. (“The Moving Finger” includes the following: “The letters are sent indiscriminately and serve the purpose of working off some frustration in the writer’s mind. As I say, it’s definitely pathological. And the craze grows….“)
Hate letters are the ancestors of today’s abusive tweets and social media comments. There is, however, a difference. Whereas hate mail isn’t public, abusive tweets threatening rape or calling the victim an “ugly cow” are. This has a larger impact as the hatred is seen by many more people and so is much more distressing.
Social media platforms must take such abuse seriously. It can, and does, lead to suicides – especially if the victims already have low self-esteem. It can escalate and lead to false rumours, as happened with Lord McAlpine – libelled by Sally Bercow. Even worse, it could lead to action against the victim.
This is not a case of freedom of speech being blocked. It’s a case of free speech that is liable to cause harm to others being punished. Anybody who tries to justify abuse using arguments that they support freedom of speech is confusing “freedom of speech” with “free speech”. Freedom of Speech is the right to communicate opinions and ideas – and censoring these is one of the first signs of a restrictive society that can, and does, lead to totalitarianism. It is not, however, a right to “free speech” where you can call for the rape of women, or abuse others through words or images. Freedom of Speech also implies responsibilities that justify that freedom.
There are people who would happily ban or restrict social media and even much of the Internet completely. In the latter case, this includes David Cameron, the UK’s prime minister, who has called on search engines to create blocks for searches for abusive pornography or be forced to do so by law. Such calls will increase, unless the relevant sites (social media, search engines, etc.) show that they accept the responsibilities of their public position, and actively look at ways of fighting, blocking or reporting abuse themselves.
Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Recent Posts
- Apple & disruptive innovation: 4 questions innovators need to ask before moving forward!
- X-mas Advertising: John Lewis, M&S and Debenhams Christmas Ad Campaigns Compared
- Competition or Co-operation? Collaborate & Co-operate to build and not to destroy.
- Freedom of Speech, Abuse and Social Media
- Pluralistic Ignorance
- Testing perceptions – Myers-Briggs and false appearances
- The iWatch – is this the next disruptive innovation from Apple?
- If you will it, it is no dream…
- The impact of disruptive innovation – on PCs and on Retail
- Why six-sigma, just-in-time and lean manufacturing are dangerous!
- Entrpreneurs 2012 – Con-Trick or Conference: a review!
- Microsoft’s Surface and Disruptive Innovation!
Archives
Topic List
Tag Cloud
AIIP Amazon analysis Apple applegate AWARE bias Bible Bing case study change China CI communication competitive analysis Competitive Intelligence Competitive Strategy competitor analysis competitors counter-intelligence decision making disinformation disruptive innovation Education ethics exalead Facebook Gaza Genesis Google Google Squared India industrial espionage information information collection innovation intelligence ipad iran islam Israel Key intelligence topics KITs lateral thinking leadership leaks LinkedIn management marketing marketing intelligence Microsoft networking news news analysis Other plagiarism privacy product development Sarah Palin scenario planning SCIP search engine search engines searching Security social media statistics strategy terrorism Twitter Wikileaks Wikipedia WolframAlpha yahoo! YaubaBlogroll
- AWARE – Competitive Intelligence for Business Success AWARE’s web-site – lots of options to learn more about CI and MI.
- Julian's The Write Way – How to produce good documentation
- Miriyummy – recipes & stories behind them
Competitive Intelligence Blogs, etc.
Ideas for Marketing and Information
Search Information
Worth a visit...
Latest Tweets…
- RT @AIIP: The world of social media is changing and InfoPros involved in any form of research need to know how to get the best from it. Joi… 20 hours ago
- The latest AWARE Weekly Update! paper.li/awareci?share_… Thanks to @cyb_detective @IngridVasiliu @AricToler #strategy #business 6 days ago
- RT @AIIP: Expand your #AIIP23 conference experience by registering for a #conference #workshop. Our pre- and post-conference #virtual work… 1 week ago
- The latest AWARE Weekly Update! paper.li/awareci?share_… Thanks to @AricToler @kmevangelist @Yaolri #strategy #business 1 week ago
- When researching a new topic there’s no magic bullet. It’s mostly about sheer, dogged persistence. 7 tips from a to… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 2 weeks ago
- The latest AWARE Weekly Update! paper.li/awareci?share_… Thanks to @Scoundrel666 #strategy #business 2 weeks ago
- one person followed me // automatically checked by fllwrs.com 2 weeks ago
- one person followed me and one person unfollowed me // automatically checked by fllwrs.com 3 weeks ago
- This should be obvious. The reason it isn't is part of the problem we all have. I recently was looking at two comp… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 3 weeks ago
- The latest AWARE Weekly Update! paper.li/awareci?share_… Thanks to @SomnusScientif1 @RichardEudes @WSaaSHQ #strategy #business 3 weeks ago
Competitive Intelligence News
- 6 Competitive Intelligence Tactics - Advertising Specialty Institute March 23, 20236 Competitive Intelligence Tactics Advertising Specialty Institute
- DemandLab Reveals 'Insentric' Marketing Intelligence Platform - Demand Gen Report March 21, 2023DemandLab Reveals 'Insentric' Marketing Intelligence Platform Demand Gen Report
- Marketing intelligence platform makes Australian debut at Marketing Live - Prolific North March 21, 2023Marketing intelligence platform makes Australian debut at Marketing Live Prolific North
- Sports Marketing Intelligence Software Market Size and Share ... - Digital Journal March 21, 2023Sports Marketing Intelligence Software Market Size and Share ... Digital Journal
- Competitive Intelligence Tools Market Research Report 2023-2033 ... - Los Alamos Monitor March 23, 2023Competitive Intelligence Tools Market Research Report 2023-2033 ... Los Alamos Monitor
Thank you for this blog. I am currently in a government class and this offered more clarity into what I am writing about. I will give you credit in my discussion. Thanks for taking time to blog.
Kayce